Brutally honest validation · v19.5 framework

95% of startup ideas
are dead on arrival.
Find out before you waste a year.

We test demand against real search numbers — how many people a month look for what you want to build. In parallel we read the open web: competitors, prices, free tools, regulators. Every claim that matters is backed by a source link. Ten detectors probe the idea from different angles. The verdict is blunt — no flattery.

  INPUT · describe your idea0 / ...

Private by default. After the verdict you choose: keep private, share a link (view-only, or view + comment), or publish to the board.

How it works

Three steps, a few minutes, and you get a straight verdict.

STEP 01

Describe your idea

Write 1-3 clear sentences. Add who it is for, where you will sell first, and how you might charge.

STEP 02

We run the ten killer-patterns

We check demand, competitors, free alternatives, platform risk, public sources, and whether people hurt enough to change how they already do things. Every serious claim needs evidence.

STEP 03

Brutal verdict with sources

You get NO-GO, WATCHLIST, TEST or GO, a score out of 100, the strict checks that capped the idea, and the first action to take.

The ten killers

Most ideas die from one of ten patterns. We check for all of them.

Open catalog

Recent verdicts · anonymous and public

I
REFORMULATE0/100Other
Russia·0·💬 0·1mo ago
I
NO-GO71/100Gaming
Global·0·💬 0·1mo ago
I
NO-GO62/100Безопасность ИИ
USA·0·💬 0·1mo ago
I
NO-GO57/100B2B SaaS / AI-аналитика
Global·0·💬 0·1mo ago
I
NO-GO62/100ИИ-аналитика соцсетей и новостей
Global·0·💬 0·1mo ago
I
NO-GO49/100Умная садовая техника
Global·0·💬 0·1mo ago
Each verdict is public. Click any line to read the full report and discussion.See all verified ideas

Compared

A general-purpose AI will flatter you. We will not.

CAPABILITY
IdeaTribunal
Regular AI assistant
Live demand check from search data
Public web evidence with source links
10 killer-pattern detectors covering every angle
9 hard checks that limit the verdict
A plain falsifier for every claim
Brutal NO-GO when the idea is dead
2-week action plan for WATCHLIST / TEST

Pricing

Save 60 days. Pay once you are sure.

Free gives you three idea checks a month. Premium adds private ideas, Refine, and a two-week action plan.

Free
$0/month
  • 3 idea checks / month
  • Public anonymous reports
  • Access to the idea board
Start free
MOST POPULAR
Premium
Price unavailable
  • Private idea checks
  • Refine workspace
  • Two-week action plan
See Premium

Plan details, currency, and the annual option are on the pricing page. Compare full plans

© 2026 IdeaTribunal · Built for honest foundersbuild 352fd842 · 2026-08-03